All tales

A story

Who tells the truth?

Draft: written by an AI helper and not yet checked by a teacher.

Tap a paragraph to see it in words.

Three children play a riddle game. Each one either always tells the truth or always lies. The first says: the second is lying. The second says: the third is lying. The third says: the first two are both lying.

Three children , , , each always truthful () or always lying (). says ' lies'; says ' lies'; says ' and both lie'.

; ; ; .

Suppose the third is truthful. Then the first two both lie. But the first said the second lies, and since the first is a liar, that is false, so the second is truthful. That clashes with the second being a liar. So the third is not truthful.

Try . Then and . But means ' lies' is false, so , a contradiction. Hence .

, but : ✗. So .

So the third lies. The second said the third lies, which is true, so the second is truthful. The first said the second lies, which is false, so the first lies.

With , the claim of , ' lies', is true, so . The claim of , ' lies', is false, so .

.

The answer: only the second child tells the truth. Check the third: the claim that both lie is false because the second is truthful, which fits a liar. The surprise: the one in the middle was the honest one, and the one with the boldest claim was lying.

The answer is : only tells the truth. The surprise is that the one in the middle was honest.

✓.

Letters of words: 670 → 244 → 5.

How to read the signs

  • t A: 1 if A tells the truth, 0 if A lies
  • if and only if
  • then; it follows that
  • and
  • is one of
  • the triple t A, t B, t C